Despite its crumbling Victorian façade, the deteriorating Willard Asylum for the Chronic Insane offers poignant insights into the lives of its inhabitants—sometimes marked by fleeting moments of joy, while at other times overshadowed by profound tragedy.
Contrary to the grim stereotypes associated with the term “asylum,” places like Willard aimed to provide a more compassionate environment for those grappling with mental illness. In the early 1800s, individuals lacking proper care and unable to fend for themselves were often relegated to overcrowded and poorly equipped almshouses. In response to these dire conditions, New York’s Surgeon General, Dr. Sylvester D. Willard, proposed the establishment of a state-operated mental hospital. Remarkably, Abraham Lincoln endorsed this proposal just six days before his untimely demise.
In 1869, Willard welcomed its inaugural patient, Mary Rote, described as “demented and deformed” after enduring a decade in an almshouse. This marked the beginning of a distressing trend, with subsequent admissions including individuals who had been shackled since childhood and even one who arrived in a chicken crate. The prevailing lack of understanding about mental disabilities transformed Willard into a de facto dumping ground for individuals deemed undesirable by society. The patients spanned a wide spectrum of afflictions, ranging from severe mental and physical handicaps to conditions labeled with terms like “nervousness,” “chronic” and “acute” insanity, “feeblemindedness,” and “lunacy.”
Designed in the typical Victorian institutional style, the asylum featured separate wings for men and women, each designated to accommodate varying levels of violence. The administrative buildings were centrally located. Initially intended for agricultural purposes, the asylum operated its own farm, which was tended to by the patients. Despite their confinement, patients enjoyed various amenities such as a bowling alley, movie theater, and gymnasium on the premises. The hospital offered a range of treatments, including electro-shock therapy and ice baths, housed in dedicated facilities. On-site, there is a cemetery with numbered markers concealing the identities of the thousands buried there.
Willard Asylum gained notable attention due to the discovery of numerous dusty suitcases found in the attic. These suitcases were brought by patients upon their admission to the hospital and contained personal mementos that offer a glimpse into their lives. Handwritten luggage tags identified the owners: Earl B. brought along a newspaper clipping on a “Smuggling Plot,” while Virginia W. brought a clown doll.
When patients passed away at Willard, their personal belongings remained unclaimed by anyone outside the institution. Unable to discard them, the staff carefully stored and cataloged the suitcases in the attic. The Willard Suitcase Project now endeavors to piece together information about the owners of these suitcases. Photos of the luggage, meticulously packed by the patients and their families, suggest a belief that they were only temporarily residing at the asylum.
In the 19th century, society struggled with how to accommodate individuals who didn’t conform to its social norms, leading to their confinement in institutions. Although those who resided and passed away at Willard have largely faded from collective memory, their personal effects left behind in the deserted asylum serve as a poignant reminder of their existence.
Today, the land once occupied by the asylum is owned by the Willard Drug Treatment Campus. However, due to security concerns, the campus is hesitant to permit tourists to explore its grounds. While annual walking tours of the asylum have been offered in the past, there haven’t been any announcements regarding future tours.
Also Recommended: Zelda Fitzgeralds Abandoned Sanatorium